Showing 170 comments

cw said:

On: 1st Jun, 2012 at 19:50

…to put it mildly, you’re putting it mildly. Very nicely written though! I couldn’t have done better :). I wasn’t too impressed by the ‘American Colony’ series. The episode doesn’t even scrape the surface of what it means to be a Hutterite 🙁 too bad.

Casey said:

On: 4th Jul, 2012 at 05:33

I’m not a Hutterite, but I respect that way of life. I find the show charming and believe people know already that the colony is religious. It shows they are human with real human problems. This show is tame compared to 99% of the others on TV, and that’s a GOOD thing! I find it a really good show. I just wish Bertha was my mom. What a beautiful way of life they (you) all have.



Gene said:

On: 31st Jul, 2012 at 03:43

amen, Casey!!

William said:

On: 1st Jun, 2012 at 21:39

For a group removed from society, I was amazed at the language and the drinking
as well as the lack of respect shown by the younger generation toward the older generation. What are the consequences for those youngster for breaking the rules?
Will that be shown later?

Mark Waldner said:

On: 1st Jun, 2012 at 23:55

I’m not sure if consequences for disrespect, etc. will be shown in later episodes as I have no way of knowing other than by checking the trailers and episode guides.

But all Hutterite parents have a responsible to their children. As they get older, the responsibility is shared with other members of the colony, including the German teacher and if serious enough the community leaders would become involved.



Dariusleut girl said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 04:04

Thank you Mark, for your comments on this film. We were discussing it the other day, and one of the points that we made (regarding “a pig for the party”) was that although that may be the usual manner and talk when they get ready for the harvest party, they knew they were being filmed and in no way did they have to ‘show off’ like they did; to me it is more ‘drama’ and ‘acting’. What a light to show the world…
I am of the ‘Darius’ group and in no way do our elders not want us to have an education, but they don’t want us to go to the outside world to do it, esp. joining in with the phys ed. seems to me a deliberate cry for attention more than a concern for the education of their children….
What the “outside world” thinks of Hutterites in general after this film will be warped, unless they know us, and unfortunately a lot of colonies are already reserved when it comes to the media and filming; this is just an example of what the media wants from us, and what some of us are willing to give…
Thanks for setting the record straight; too bad you can’t send this article direct to National Geographic.



Rika said:

On: 18th Sep, 2012 at 17:12

I watched a few episodes on Nat Geo, as a member of the outside world, I don’t believe I have a warped view. I understand, I believe, the way of life that your colonies achieve. I also acknowledge, as a young woman, that head strong desire to be independent. Many women feel that. Even if the show was hyped either by the young people of the colony or by Nat Geo my view isn’t warped.
I don’t think poorly of the colonies or even think that sort of behaviour is abnormal. Humans are flawed and that’s been made apparent, but I don’t think you should generalize us folks that live on the outside world to be so foolish as to believe everything we see on TV or hear from other people with weight.
It is what it is. Religion is important to the colony, and that was made very adamant with the fears the young ones being excommunicated and not able to be baptised. I’m sorry for the wrong you felt the colonies recieved.



Robin said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 15:23

Hi,
As an observant Jewish woman, I found the show interesting in that it illustrates many similarities between our cultures. We too promote modest dress, covering of our heads, separation from the mainstream, etc. What concerned me was the way education was depicted. I see from other comments here that education within the community is promoted, but not in public schools. While that is similar to Judaism, no one would shun someone for going to a public school and/or pursuing a higher education. I find that disturbing. Great beauty can be found in the integration of science and religion, for example, see Gerald Shroeder, in his book, The Science of God”. I understand the need to limit negative influences, but from the series, it appears many of the community members could be more educated, in general. It appeared to me that the elders, and/or the parents, were specifically discouraging the pursuit of knowledge, something Jews would never do. Are other colonies more educated than King Ranch or was the perspective just skewed by the directors of the show?



Ian said:

On: 14th Jun, 2012 at 23:55

Hi Robin
Thank you for your comment.

The Hutterite culture is very diverse in many areas. There are many differences that exist between the different groups of Hutterites and even from colony to colony. This is particularly true in education. In most colonies students attend public schools which are located on the colony. However, not all Hutteriter believe in only educating their students to grade 8 or 9. There are many colonies in which students are greatly encouraged to take their grade 12. In others, grade 12 is a requirement. Many colonies have their own teachers who received their bachelor of education degree from an accredited university. However, in the majority of colonies, the teachers are hired by the public school boards. Many Hutterite students have gone on to take further training in community collages or trade schools. Education is highly valued and supported by the elders of some community. But, as you saw on the documentary, it is not valued or promoted by all.

Of course, we are concerned with some aspects or subjects that our students have to take, but we feel that as long as we have the freedom to discuss these sensitive issues with our students and provide alternative views, our students will not be harmed by what they learn. The world does not consist of just black and white but all ranges of colour. We feel it is important to teach our students to see and perceive what is of value and discard what is harmful.



CJ said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 05:36

Jerry,

Respectfully I beg to differ with you. If one shows only the ‘good’ in people and not the struggle then is one showing such person in an honest light? None of us are perfect except for our Lord. By showing true life struggle with the good and how it is addressed in future shows how would one be able to relate? It is my sincere prayer the show will educate non Hutterite Christians that there is hope we can learn to live in the world yet be separate from it.

KW said:

On: 1st Jun, 2012 at 23:46

I am so very thankful that someone took the time to address this issue. As Christians, we need to be a light and that’s missing in the series.

Jerry said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 03:56

Thank you for addressing this issue. It’s very well written. Also am really disappointed at the lack of respect for their elders and the foul language; one can only imagine what it’s like off camera. These poor people have no idea what Hutterite life is all about or why they live a communal lifestyle. I really hope I’m right in thinking that it’s all been scripted and not reality.

Ashamed said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 04:00

Thanks Mark for posting this.

I believe that this American Colony has slid to an all time low, corrupted group of people who need a revision, reformation and revival.

Here is a prime example that by discarding the faith values of our Godly Christian forefathers and adopting new ways, which actually have little meaning to us, such people break with the old but do not acquire the new (Rev.3: 15-16). As a result, they deteriorate mentally and morally. The emotional conflict in such persons leads to undo lawlessness, disorder and chaos.

Hurt but not Angry said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 04:36

I actually find this film more in-tone with what real Hutterites are about:
http://www.nfb.ca/film/the_hutterites

CJ said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 05:26

I truly feel saddened by the above statement. I never even hear of Hutterites until the show and found it showed them in a light that they are human, not perfect nor saints, just good non perfect humans who like anyone else struggle to live right. As a mother and a grandmother watching it made me even wish my family and I had been born into such a colony. However I trust God had me born right where he wanted me. I hope other Hutterite colonies will not be to harsh on the colony who is doing the show. I helped my heart desire to serve God and others around me more than ever and to strive for a more simple life. I’m thankful to of been able to watch the first show and look forward to the next. I pray it will help other Christians see a beautiful alternative to
being able to live in but not of this world.

Schatzie said:

On: 21st Jun, 2012 at 19:37

Well said. I couldn’t agree more. I’d never heard of the Hutterites, and seeing this show made me think what a lovely bunch. So a few bad words are said, those who pretend to be the most angelic are often the worst. I think they’re wonderful people who struggle with every day issues like everyone else in this world. It isn’t easy to grow up with such traditions in this day and age and they somehow make it work in a way where outsiders can think “what a neat group of people!”.. i admire them for being so brave and willing to let others in.



Gordon Broom said:

On: 13th Jul, 2012 at 16:28

I watched two episodes last night and loved it. It brought back memories of the holiness camp meetings my family went to all summer long growing up where everyone had their assignments and chores. I agree that this was made for entertainment but what I saw was a loving group of Christians sharing their lives together in community. Some situations in the show were dysfunctional, some of it very functional. I saw a group of wonderful Christian people people working in community pleasing God, supporting and loving one another and making some mistakes along the way which is part of the human experience. God bless the Hutterites. You are in my prayers.

Jeffrey Stokely said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 15:17

I was looking forward to seeing the show and was a bit disappointed by NatGeo’s portrayal of the Hutterites. They were unlike any Hutterites I have known; so I blame the NatGeo Channel, and not the Hutterites. What else did you expect? The “World” is not going to understand or appreciate your commitment to the Gospel. Please hold fast to those things which make you who you are!

I would like to send a donation to the King Ranch Colony, as I mostly feel bad for them that their cattle did not bring in what they expected. Could you send me a private e-mail regarding where I can mail a cheque? (my address is above) Thanks, and God bless all of you!

Benjamin Wurtz said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 16:20

Thank-you Mark for this update. I am scared that the whole world will see the Hutterites like on the “American Colony” . King Ranch Colony is sort of an ‘outcast’ amongst the Dariusleut.

Linda said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 19:00

Thank you so much, Mark! Very well said. It’s only a matter of time when someone will ask me about this series on my own blog, so I will create a link to this response right now. I really appreciate this!
I saw the trailer and so far haven’t watched anything else…guess it left me with a bad taste in my mouth. Yes, people who know us will know that this is not a representation of all Hutterites. However, there are probably more who don’t know us, and who will see this as how all of us live. Someone told me yesterday, “Most of this looks staged,anyway….. And why would National Graphic stoop to something like this?” Good question!

Mark Waldner said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 19:09

All our readers: Let’s keep in mind that members of King Ranch did not intend for the series to be what it seems to be turning out to be, with a bit of a focus on what we as Hutterites would call the negatives.

If they had known that things would fall out as they did, they would never have participated or they would have done things quite differently, their leaders acknowledge.

Further let’s keep in mind that the series wasn’t directed by King Ranch members, but by the producers of American Colony, whose main purpose it is to sell it to the public. King Col had little control over that. Other directors might have chosen to focus on the positives, with the tradeoff being less appeal to a mass audience, but producers of American Colony chose otherwise, not King Col.

Chris said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 20:53

if king ranch still belived in god they wouldn’t have made the videos!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Becca said:

On: 5th Jun, 2012 at 23:35

*God* should always be capitalized



Walter said:

On: 18th Jun, 2012 at 20:44

National Geographic has put the Hutterite community’s lifestyle out there for all to see and each one of us has our own opinion of what we saw. It does not matter what we think, though.
Since you live for God and seek to do His will in all things, it would naturally follow that it is only His opinion that matters.



Schatzie said:

On: 21st Jun, 2012 at 19:43

This show is probably the best thing that has happened to your community. People often reject what they don’t understand, or what they don’t agree with.

For once a religious group is embraced by the “English” people are relateable and we respect that. We don’t see them a crazies cursing and disrespecting, but as people trying to adapt their traditions to the world they live in today. You can’t expect people to not want to expand their horizons and grow.

Often they don’t want to make the colony look bad, but help it with the knowledge they’re receiving.

They’re clearly good people who are loving of their traditions– You don’t see anyone running away.

Give them a break!

N.M. said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 21:15

If you’d care for an “outside” perspective, I can only say that King Ranch may very well be attracting more interest from the general public than the other colonies you speak of. Why? Because people want Real. People of “the world,” (MY world, by the way), are greatly turned off by judgmentalism and collective spiritual narcissism. I have had a passing interest in the Hutterian way, only because some of my husband’s origins are rooted in that culture. Every week day our children wake up and excitedly go to school. You’d judge it as a “worldly” school with “worldly influences.” I beg your pardon? We are proud of our children’s school. ‘Influences’ happen and are part of life in the ‘real’ world. Consider how you might be “influencing” your children that you work so hard to isolate from many good and wonderful people out here! Consider that you may be teaching them to judge and condemn others. To become spiritual narcissists. To have no empathy or compassion for anyone different from themselves. See, we try to guard our children from those influences. Not sure if I’d call them “worldly,” as I have not yet figured out a label. Perhaps “Mean-spirited” and “Unkind” would suffice. The more I learn, the more I have to say that I intend to “guard” our children from some of the traits I see being promoted in your lifestyle. There are certainly admirable aspects of your community life and I have enjoyed becoming acquainted with some of them, but your Pharisaical behavior really serves to negate them. And, it is possible that your reaction, your need to shore up your ‘special and unique’ identity, is really just deep group insecurity. Do you realize how smug it is to have the audacity to assume that you are actually some sort of “light” on the hill when you judge and condemn others? It’s a joke. It’s utterly offensive. As long as you behave in sanctimonious ways, you will continue to turn people off. You should be honored to have ANY interest from “the world” that you judge. In fact, you ought to thank ‘the world.’ They generously give your glory-seekers a platform.

Mark Waldner said:

On: 2nd Jun, 2012 at 21:54

If you’d leave your email addy NM, we’d reply in private. We don’t want to turn this blog into a battering ram. Thank you



N.M said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 00:19

Mark–thank you for the offer. I believe your message was quite straight forward and my response was directly proportionate–from my ‘world’. No need for a battle 🙂 Peace!



dc said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 06:12

Wow NM…Live and let live…..God Bless our Hutterites. I work at a company that caters to the Colonies and have made some wonderful friends. They have helped me and in turn I have helped them. Judge not lest ye be judged.



Linda said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 01:26

Hello N.M. (-:
Of course, we care for “outside perspective”. That’s why we have our blogs enabled so people can comment! If you want to see and experience “real” do come for a visit and worship, work, dine, converse…with us. But please don’t rely on and conclude that a TV show is real.
Before, I go any further, I just want to say, I agree with everything Mark said, (But, you probably already know that.) And I know that he didn’t write any of this in a mean-spirited way, quite the opposite. It was purely written to show how we feel about this series and to point out why we take a stand against certain things.
As far as you taking offence of Mark’s reference to ‘worldly’, is concerned, sorry, but it’s biblical and as Christians we try to live our lives as outlined in Titus 2, to name just one scripture passage where ‘worldly’ is used. We understand all too well, how some people don’t see it from our perspective, have other beliefs and thus, say all kinds of hurtful things… I don’t know, are they trying to justify something, make us feel bad, change us, or is it purely, they don’t know any better.
In any case, we forgive you for saying we’re Pharisees, Narcissist, glory-seekers and that you think that we’re mean-spirited, judgmental, unkind, insecure, sanctimonious…who, “have no empathy or compassion for anyone different from themselves.” And that you feel you have to guard your children from “some of the traits I see being promoted in your lifestyle.” Harsh, for sure, but we will not hold it against you, because there must be some other issue at play here, something that probably isn’t even related to the topic we’re discussing. Once again, come for a visit, bring your whole family…



HazelNut said:

On: 20th Jun, 2012 at 13:27

This is a wonderful response to NM’s post, which I found unsettling and not necessarily representative of “worldly” views.



Disillusioned said:

On: 27th Jul, 2012 at 04:25

To Linda,

Not sure what you mean come visit us, worship and dine, a friend received a message from one of the Colony members that they charge for giving any tours at the ranch. Why would someone have to pay money to visit and worship with someone to understand them. Am I missing something here?



Marty Teeters, Fairbanks, AK said:

On: 13th Jul, 2012 at 11:53

N.M.
Is the “real world” the one you think G*d wants us to have or should we be desperately striving after a purer heart and try to live our lives “in the world BUT NOT OF the world”?

Debbie Wollman said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 01:46

very well said..

CJ said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 02:43

I’m hoping in future episodes it will show how the negative issues were dealt with.
Was wondering what any of you think about the below Bible verse? Maybe I am understanding it wrong. How do Hutterites feel about spreading God’s word?
If one stays to themselves how can there be hope for others?

Matthew 5:16
King James Version (KJV)
16 Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.

Ian said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 04:09

CJ, thank you for your questions.
Hutterites most definitely believe in spreading God’s word. There are many ways in which Hutterites perform missions close to home or even in other countries. Do all Hutterites actively participate? No. However, that is most likely true for many other Christian churches. This too has a scriptural basis – as not all are missionaries or disciples.

Also, how do you define “stays to themselves” as not being a light? Light remains light, no matter how distant. If it is a true light, it will shine forth and all will see it. Just because Hutterites choose to live in rural areas does not automatically mean they are shutting themselves off from society. Would you apply the same label to a farmer and his family who live by themselves and only travel to town when they need supplies?

Hutterite colonies, contrary to what many may think, are not a “closed system.” The NG documentary is ample proof of that. Hutterite colonies have always been open to people joining or leaving if they choose to. People have been making documentaries or carrying out in-dept studies of the Hutterites almost as soon as they came to North America. Though somewhat reserved, Hutterites have for the most part allowed these “intrusions” to be made. Is this not letting your light shine?

Thanks again for your questions!



Robin Kincaid said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 22:12

Ian is very correct here. In many ways, these Hutterites are living no differently then my Prussian ancestors and cousins (Lutherans) who came to farm the Dakotas in the 1870s; they are still farming today and in many ways still live rather remote and only come to town on weekends (or less often) for supplies and to catch up on local news. City folks think they are strange! As a first generation city gal (I live in the suburbs of Seattle), my cousins think I am the strange person. I don’t even speak the old, low German (platt-Deutsch) that the old people speak. Religiously I am not an outcast, but culturally and often linguistically I certainly am.

So, let’s not pick on the Hutterites. These people are far more welcoming and kind, if you approach them kindly, then many bigoted, unaccepting folks I’ve met in countless small towns and farms across America.

N.M said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 04:45

..in response to Linda’s points:
L: But please don’t rely on and conclude that a TV show is real.
N. Of course the show is not a real reflection of Hutterites in general. I meant ‘real’ in terms of the openness to integrating with the outside world. That is something that is appealing to people out here. We’re curious! We care! The same way that you enjoy outsiders showing interest in your world, those of us ‘outside’ have a lot from our world that we’d enjoy sharing with our Hutterite friends.

L: And I know that he didn’t write any of this in a mean-spirited way, quite the opposite. It was purely written to show how we feel about this series and to point out why we take a stand against certain things.
N: Mark actually wrote his assessment very well. I am just responding to what can’t help but be slams against major elements of our and our children’s and family and friend’s lives. I am responding to the generalization of labeling those out here as “wordly,” a word that obviously is loaded with negative connotations in your life. In the same way you do not want to be perceived through generalizations and judgments, neither do many folks outside of your communities.

L: As far as you taking offence of Mark’s reference to ‘worldly’, is concerned, sorry, but it’s biblical and as Christians we try to live our lives as outlined in Titus 2, to name just one scripture passage where ‘worldly’ is used.
N: Luke 18 & Matthew 7

L: We understand all too well, how some people don’t see it from our perspective, have other beliefs and thus, say all kinds of hurtful things… I don’t know, are they trying to justify something, make us feel bad, change us, or is it purely, they don’t know any better.
N: My thoughts as well in reading the above response to the Nat. Geo series featuring the King Colony…a series that I have greatly enjoyed. I was rather surprised to see that some took issue with this. I think that Nat. Geo tried to be as respectful as they could, and, as an ‘outsider,’ it was kind’ve nice to see some Hutterites meet us half-way in our world. When I saw Claudia’s eye-makeup, it was not a big deal. It did not shape the way I perceive Hutterites as a whole. I thought–how great that Claudia can still be a part of her community and have some of her own self-expression! When I saw Wesley sitting at a table with a few ‘outside’ waitresses, I thought–Ha! Not going to work! Certainly not a “date.” But, he handled it so well, and he knew his limits! It did not destroy him. It made him a neat, friendly and kind person to remember! Some of the same elements that I love about my born-Hutterite father-in-law! At a human level..while we know we’re different, it still gives us ‘warm fuzzies’ to find common ground, because, in spite of our differences in lives, beliefs, and commitments–we’re still human. I spent the first 18 years of my life in evangelical mission work. I can attest to the fact that, back then, I was not genuinely interested in anyone outside of my belief-church-sphere–other than converting them. They were all ‘lost,’ ‘wrong,’ and ‘worldly.’ I now cringe when I see it in action elsewhere. It is another reason I particularly appreciated Nat. Geo’s approach. We don’t miss that this is a completely different way of life. And, I am well aware of the faith aspect.

L:In any case, we forgive you for saying we’re Pharisees, Narcissist, glory-seekers and that you think that we’re mean-spirited, judgmental, unkind, insecure, sanctimonious…who, “have no empathy or compassion for anyone different from themselves.” And that you feel you have to guard your children from “some of the traits I see being promoted in your lifestyle.”
Harsh, for sure, but we will not hold it against you, because there must be some other issue at play here, something that probably isn’t even related to the topic we’re discussing.
N: I did not ask for forgiveness 😉 I think that you can agree that it is no more harsh than the innate awful implications and loaded avoidance of ‘the World…”

L: Once again, come for a visit, bring your whole family..
N: Thank you, Linda..and you’re always welcome to visit our home and our son’s school too! I think we can agree that ALL children on our planet need our collective love and kind regard.

Derek said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 13:31

N.M I think we need to clarify the definition of “worldly”. As a Hutterite but more importantly as born again christian I believe that the bible is The word of God in which God shows us his plan for mankind and also gives us standards by which we should live. So according to God’s book there is right and wrong. So we have a choice now, follow God and his standards or follow our own desires. The biblical meaning of “world” is simply this “without God”. It certainly does not mean “outside the boundaries of a colony”

Jake said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 12:03

King Ranch IS a Dariusleut colony in good standing, not an “outcast” as some would like us to believe. Most colonies today are a mess morally and spiritually and the elders are no longer in control. Why are any of you watching this? Hutterites are not allowed to have TV or even radio. Such hypocrites. Neither are they allowed to have pictures. All of this is in the “rule book” and you know it. It makes us look like a dishonest society when we do the opposite. People have to lie, ad they learn to do it with a straight face. OMG

John said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 19:31

Jake,
Did you know that you don’t actually need the TV or radio if you have the internet 🙂 ?



Lily said:

On: 6th Jul, 2012 at 03:53

Jake,
If the “rule book” states that you are not to have tv or radio then I am slightly confused as to how a computer and internet access would be acceptable. I believe your own words were..”such hypocrites”. Pot calling the Kettle Black?

tuggles said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 16:13

As a non-Hutterite I am watching the series with a great deal of interest . I think one of the positives out comes is that it has shown me that Hutterites are not some ” strange , weird , scary ” group of misfits , but are just normal , hard working people, trying to hold on to their faith and beliefs . One of the big things that jumped out at me in the series is just how stilted, and scripted it comes accross . It is very obvious that the camera is not just capturing a sneak peek into the everday lives , but is setting up and promoting manufactured situations .

N.M said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 17:59

Thank you, Derek. I am quite familiar with the rigid interpretations of the scriptures when it comes to deciding what constitutes ‘worldliness.’ I just would like to say that there is rigidity and much legalism in strictly following the letter of the law. But, what about the SPIRIT of the law? That seems to be missing…that is where the Love is…and God is Love (1John 4:8)! Also, ..the wisdom of God is “full of mercy”, and “without partiality”. (James 3:17) And, I always wonder, when speaking of Christianity…doctrine, ‘law’.. What Would Jesus Do? Because, after all, many times, Jesus gets lost in the mix! Are we following Jesus or men? Because, in fact, Jesus warned the people against THE DOCTRINE of the Pharisees, who are will known to have believed in endless punishment. (See Matt. 16:6; compare verse 12.) There is no doubt, that the doctrines of the Pharisees were of a PARTIAL nature. Jesus was impartial in his teachings. He was the friend of publicans and sinners, and for this, the Pharisees hated him. This was the great point on which he differed from the Pharisees. Their doctrine peculiarly was a doctrine of cruelty, wrath, and partiality. His was a doctrine of Love, compassion, and universal grace. No person, who will make the comparison fairly, can avoid coming to this result……

N.M said:

On: 3rd Jun, 2012 at 18:12

@ ‘Hurt but not Angry’…thank you for sharing this video! Very nicely done and informative.

Sonny said:

On: 5th Jun, 2012 at 16:30

Not one, but ALL clips of this lost colony are simply disgraceful, disrespectful and pitiful! Where did these people grow up? Certainly not in a true Christian Hutterite community. There’s the evident and clear living proof of ‘wordly’ influence. As touchy and sensitive as it might be to some outsiders being stated as ‘wordly’, go visit a well-grounded Hutterite colony and you will see how damaging and destructive ‘worldy’ influence has been to this King colony. This is obviously the result of having no moral and godly backbone. Anyone watching these ‘acted’ misleading clips, PLEASE don’t assume this as a true portrayal of the Hutterian Church. For accurate information on the Hutterian Church visit http://www.hutterites.org
National Geographic has certainly exposed itself to many of us. We know now what their backbone is made of!

Kelly Hofer said:

On: 5th Jun, 2012 at 21:34

I have tried for years to tell the Hutterite story with photos. Most of the time I feel that I have fallen short of my expectations. Not because I didn’t tell a story, but because I really didn’t make anyone care. Yes I have beautiful, interesting photos, but very few that make us think, question, discuss and change for the better. Simply because i was censored and never could. I have a few questions for all of you.

1. Was it the intention of National Geographic to create a all-encompassing film to portray all hutterites equally?
2. Is there anything wrong with NG, a for not-for-profit organization, to obtain permission from hutterites to shoot a film on the colony for profit if they got consent to do so?
3. Can a story be told, one that draws people in and makes them care, if there is no emotion?
4. Does wearing makeup differ from dressing nicely to make somebody more appealing?
5. Can’t people not be different from each other, and still be called the same thing [hutterites]?
6. If 50+ people live together and see each other all day, isn’t there naturally going to be conflict?
7. A colony doesn’t offer high-school, can it not be expected that parents would be willing to compromise a culture based education for none at all?
8. If i follow you around for a few months, will I witness conflicts, arguments, or swearing?
9. Does management in your colony know of every nefarious activity going on in your colony, if not, do you expect that colonies management to know what was filmed?
10. Can there be a human with no flaws?
11. How does the medium of Filming differ from photography, oral storytelling, books, singing? All convey a story, and in Hutterite history especially; they are quite violent, graphic and blunt.
12. If i filmed you, would your actions be the same as when not being filmed?
13. Is it so horrible that some hutterites are not humble and willing to bare their lives in order to allow some ignorance for our culture to be dispelled?

So my position is this, If someone can tell a more truthful, honest portrayal of our life, i will support it and tell as many people about it as i can. Which brings me to my final question..

14. What’s the point in wanting outsiders to know about us? What is the point in us reading newspapers, news websites, books, watch movies, listen to music, listen to radio or consume any outside media?
It’s to make us human, by learning about others. We couldn’t have learned anything as a baby without experiencing other humans. It’s the most human experience possible, to learn from and teach others. It’s how we progress as a race to understand, grow, accept and respect other humans.
~thank you

Sonny said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 14:39

Kelly, just wondering if you are a mature, baptized member of the Hutterian Church? Somehow you portray insecurity and unstableness. Tread carefully! You could become neither here nor there as N. M seems to be. I pray I’m forgiven if I’m wrong, but one gets the impression she’s been all over and still insecure to where she really stands in her faith and church.

Further on to other bloggers on the topic of education…
Education???? What is the use of ANY super-duper education if the Christian morals and foundation are lacking? It’s like owning a truck load of gold. Will the earthly gold safe your life if you had a fatal heart attack? Education can be a very powerful tool, but without a Christian foundation, what will it really do for you in the end? In the ultimate end when it will REALLY matter! Yes, education is a good blessing, but obtaining it through aggressiveness and against the blessings and approval of the church will only bring regretful consequences.
By the way, Hutterites DO get their education. Read the ‘education’ tag on http//7nn.010.mwp.accessdomain.com. The biggest struggle with Bertha and hers is rebellion, disrespect and self-will. If they would be sincere Christian links of their church, they would not run full speed into the gates of Sodom and Gomorra. One wonders if they ever ask themselves the question, “What would Jesus do?”
One certainly feels compassionate and sad for their confusion. Let’s all keep them in our prayers.



kellyhofer said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 14:49

Sonny,
No i’m not mature, baptized or a member of the church. I’m as old as Claudia in the film.
Maybe i am insecure and unstable. But weren’t we all at one time.
I’m just trying to ask fundamental questions about the show. Because when you boil it all down, the one question is “why would national geographic make a scripted reality-type” show instead of a documentary?” Think about it long and hard.



kellyhofer said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 14:56

And just to be clear. I do not defend or like the show. It’s very sub-standard.
I am asking, why did it become what it is?
I encourage you to go to my website and look around kellyhofer.com There you’ll see what i would like a series about the hutterites to look like. Make sure you also navigate to the “hutterite photos” page.



Sonny said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 15:45

Please don’t feel offended by my comment. For your age, I admire your openness and questioning… just remember as I said, tread and inquire carefully!

By the way, am really looking forward to checking out your website.



Jeff said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 17:32

Awesome photos, Kelly.



Robin Kincaid said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 22:32

I will go to your website to learn more. Thank you, Mr. Hofer.

I think you are quite mature for your age and you are trying to become more enlightened and asking a lot of questions that are quite profound. Unfortunately, because you are so obviously very intelligent and seeking answers, you may become one of those that “thinks” your way right out of the Colony. This, I fear, is why you got the response you did from one of the Hutterites here. Your religion is most admirable but to maintain it requires a lot of watchfulness over one’s behavior, constantly; and that necessitates a great deal of control by yourself and by others over you. For some, this is not the way they can live and that is why there are all those ‘outsiders.’ Also, I do not think you insecure or unstable. For many who live in tight, religious cultural groups you unfortunately will be seen as such, or accused as such just to reign you in tighter so you don’t think differently, thereby becoming a threat to others (perhaps this is how the Mennonites diverged from the Amish; the control factor became a little excessive and that in itself can cause “instability” of the mind). While I can understand it is your people’s right to live this way, for many it would be a challenge. I grew up in a typical, highly controlled German environment, I can sympathize here.



kelly hofer said:

On: 14th Jun, 2012 at 16:21

Robin.
Funny you should mention me leaving the colony. I left last Sunday.



Judi Smith said:

On: 6th Jul, 2012 at 16:48

Enjoyed your photos, were these taken at one colony or a number of them in Canada.

Your pictures show some of the things missing from the series on tv program – the members playing games, swimming ect – but then the series is a reality show and not a documentary. I do like the series but feel that they could only add to it with a little more of the true day to day happenings along with all the drama.

One thing you can say about the program is that it has a lot of people talking about the Hutterites that before didn’t even know they existed.

miranda said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 01:38

I find the show entertaining, at best, And as an “outsider” having been around the “colonists” of different Hutterite groups, that is all that it is. Most of the banter is just showing out. keep trecking on, you are loved and respected people

Tiff said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 01:45

I just watched Amercan Colony for the first time. I found it interesting, but disappointing due to language and disrespect of youth in particular toward elders. I was glad to hear this is not typical of other colonies. One question I had was concerning Hutterite beliefs. Do Hutterites believe in salvation through faith in Christ alone? I am assuming so, but wasn’t certain after reading beliefs section on the website. Thank you!

Tiff

Zack said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 04:55

I think it would be cool to come and visit because i like what you hutterites do and i would like to join the cherch but that would be hard and i would love to come and visit

Joanne Ivins said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 06:11

Glad I found your article, and able to read the comments-so diverse. As a social worker in Arizona, I have dealt professionally with many people from different cultures. I was also raised as a minister’s daughter in a Protestant church. I have enjoyed watching the American Colony show on television, and agree the religious dedication of the population is not shown in detail and rarely referred to at all. I would imagine it is eye opening for many in the world who have not heard of Hutterites in general. What I see are younger generation vs older generation struggles- a common theme we all share in life. Also the dynamic between those with power, and without. Surely interesting, and of course one group does not represent the masses. Blessings and good health to all !

rebecca said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 10:53

i’m glad they are airing this. I’m thinking on joining the Hutterites and would love more info on the colony.

CB said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 14:11

I especially loved the part where the father spoke about his son stopping school so he can work on the farm. Afterall, is school going to teach him how to fix a tractor? Um, ever hear of critical and analytical thought to problem solve. Afterall, they like their frames crooked, “The more crooked the better.” and then watching them measure the wood – “3/8’s plus 3/8’s is 6/8’s.” Obviously learning the least common denominator was useless in the community. Certainly a bunch of ignorant backwoods people.

Jeffrey Stokely said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 14:27

Well stated, Paul!

Donna in SC said:

On: 20th Jun, 2012 at 03:35

I saw this show for the first time tonight and as a Christian, I was shocked to hear so much bad language. Of course reality shows are scripted, but is this an accurate portrayal of the Hutterites colonies? I’m not here to throw a stone. I’m far from perfect and am only a Christian because of God’s grace. I was just a bit shocked by some of the behaviors.

It seems modesty is only represented in dress.

I grew up in TN next to a Mennonite community and they were the sweetest, hardworking, good neighbors. Never once did I hear anyone curse, disrespect their elders, etc.

I have never heard of the Hutterites before so perhaps I’m being a bit harsh. It just seemed for a Christian community who doesn’t like a wordly influence, this show seems a bit hipocritical.

Char Daigle said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 14:44

Just wanted to say that as an “outsider” with a limited knowledge base of Hutterite life, but, with common sense; I was neither entertained nor impressed by this program. I did not for a minute believe that it depicted a true picture of Hutterite life and/or beliefs. I feel certain there are MANY others out there who would agree with me.
Char Daigle

Pat said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 15:17

Mark: Tell me why it is that Hutterite children in Montana do not have to attend an accredited school until they are 16 years of age. Thank you!

Mark Waldner said:

On: 7th Jun, 2012 at 02:08

Actually I’m not sure why they don’t or if they don’t go to age 16; keep in mind that the elders were against sending their children to public high school in town. Perhaps it would be ok for students on this colony to attend school on the colony or obtain courses via distance education. I do know that some Darius colonies in MT have the option of gaining a high school education either via distance ed or other means.

Joe B said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 16:06

Just wanted to say I enjoy watching the show. I love learning about the Hutterite ways and get a kick out of Bertha, Claudia etc. I had never heard of a Hutterite before this show and found the information on your web site very interesting. Nat Geo again is showing the world what an amazing country we live in, with the many different cultures and lifestyles that abound in America. Bertha is the best. She makes me happy. Brutally honest, sincere sweet lady. Thanks for sharing A piece of your life with me.

N.M said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 19:54

@Kelly: Simply breath-taking snapshots of your people and your way of life as a Hutterite, Kelly. Your beautiful, generous, artistic and gracious spirit shines through in what you share with the world through your photos. Amazing work!

@Sonny:
Dear Sonny,
I speak as a person who has experienced high-demand religion from every possible angle. I’ve experienced the positives and the negatives. And one thing I’ve learned, Sonny, is that the human respect factor–the compassion and empathy factor–is often compromised in the rabid pursuit of unity. In the rabid pursuit of unity, in our little microcosms of high-demand faith & life, it is men’s commandments that often reign supreme…NOT Jesus Christ’s. And, that has sadly been made obvious through several comments on this thread. I also speak as a woman, Sonny. Perhaps your belittlement and disrespect toward women is tolerated in your world. It’s not tolerated in mine. I’m sorry if the impression given is one that makes you uncomfortable.

Sonny said:

On: 7th Jun, 2012 at 00:31

Dear N.M.
By no means did, or do I try to hurt anyone. I have never commented on blogs before, but this time I couldn’t resist. I must commend you on your writing skills. God blessed you there, but please don’t abuse His gift! Reading your well written comments simply gave me the picture of an unstable, embittered searching soul. Please do forgive me if this is not the case. But after watching the King Colony clips and then reading some of your comments, I couldn’t help but think you are justifying or supporting those sinful and disrespectful ways. Therefore, it is only natural and right of us who are part of this Church to be dismayed and concerned. Don’t you see the danger that if the general public out there will be reading your comments, they could get a false, warped impression or understanding of our belief and way of life? You wouldn’t ever want that to happen, would you?
The above words you threw into Mark’s and into the Hutterians’ face were certainly not meant to comfort or solace us, much rather the opposite. Is this Christian like? N.M. “your Pharisaical behavior really serves to negate them. And, it is possible that your reaction, your need to shore up your ‘special and unique’ identity, is really just deep group insecurity. Do you realize how smug it is to have the audacity to assume that you are actually some sort of “light” on the hill when you judge and condemn others? It’s a joke. It’s utterly offensive. As long as you behave in sanctimonious ways, you will continue to turn people off. You should be honored to have ANY interest from “the world” that you judge. In fact, you ought to thank ‘the world.’ They generously give your glory-seekers a platform.”
Here my human side would like to add, if it is only the nomadic and pietistic defamers like you who will be turned off, that is a blessing. Just kindly leave the stage! But I don’t want you to take this as a means to hurt, rather as a means to warn and clarify. Keep praying and searching.
As far as your comment, “Perhaps your belittlement and disrespect toward women is tolerated in your world,” statement is concerned, that is just another clear image of your assumptions and revengeful back-biting. Where did I belittle women in any of my comments? We treat women the way we are taught in God’s Word… with equal respect to both women and men. Our female cooks, house wives, school teachers, gardeners, etc. are all seen as equal to our male carpenters, teachers, electricians, ministers, livestock managers, etc. However, we do discourage women from speaking in church. 1 Corinthians 14:34-35
This seems to go off track. Let’s not beat around the bush here. It all boils down to what is right and wrong in the eyes of God. The National Geographic display of the Hutterian Church is falsified and wrong and therefore, sinful. Now we can go on and on and try to justify any human opinion. Let’s keep on praying for humbleness, unity and His direction. We all need His constant help as no one is perfect. We Hutterites merely strive to live as close to the example life that Jesus lived with His disciples. Yes, we are living by many man-made rules that you so sarcastically frown upon. But have you ever sought to study and seen how beautifully each of our man-made rules is based on God’s Word and Jesus’ teachings? We don’t claim to be self-righteous as you accuse us… nor do we believe the Hutterian way is the only way into heaven. We have many outside friends who live a humble devoutly life and we are so much looking forward to being together in heaven one day with everyone who live according to His ways. In closing, no offence meant… merely trying to say and do what is right in the eyes of God. Let’s keep asking ourselves in all circumstances… sincerely ask, “What would Jesus do?”



Jean said:

On: 27th Jun, 2012 at 03:52

Sonny:

Regarding “Reading your well written comments simply gave me the picture of an unstable, embittered searching soul.” That sentence is no less disturbing than some of the language and behavior depicted at the King Colony. Such language shuts down illuminating dialog and exchange of ideas, and it reflects poorly on the Hutterite faith.

Barbara Rumfield said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 20:16

I have a couple of questions about what I saw on the show and something Ian said.

“Hutterite colonies, contrary to what many may think, are not a “closed system.” The NG documentary is ample proof of that. Hutterite colonies have always been open to people joining or leaving if they choose to.”

From what I saw on the show, marriage outside of the colony was prohibited. That you had to marry with-in the faith. Ian’s response does not match up with this.

My first question is, if a non-Hutterite and a practicing Hutterite wished to marry, would it be allowed?
Second, if the marriage was allowed would the non-Hutterite be required to convert to the Hutterite religion in order to marry?

Ian said:

On: 14th Jun, 2012 at 23:01

Like many religious organizations or groups, the Hutterites have a structure or formula which they follow regarding marriage. In the Hutterite faith, one must first be a baptized member of a community before one is allowed to marry within the church. The reason for this is that we believe marriage to be a sacred institution which should not be entered into lightly. Divorce is not an option!

Should someone want to marry a nonHutterite, they would in all likelihood have to do so outside the community. Such a union would be highly impracticable in such a setting and would thus be highly unlikely.

The apostle Paul advised his followers: “Be ye not unequally yoked together with unbelievers:” (2 Cor. 6:14). I am aware that he was speaking about believer/unbeliever union. However, I will, if I may, take it in a slightly different context. We as Hutterites, have, for good or bad, a unique culture, language and internal structure. If a nonHutterite were to marry a Hutterite who practices the tenants of his/her faith and lives according to the cultural norms of the Hutterite community she/he is living in, would that not eventually cause strife or tension between the two?
That being said, such a marriage is not actually forbidden, but as I stated earlier, are very unlikely.

In our colony, we have at least 3 families who were not born into the Hutterite culture or faith but joined our community of their own free will and were baptized into the faith upon the confession of their faith. Over the years, we have had many people who have wanted to join, but in the end did not. Of all the cases, one might help to answer your questions.

A couple of years ago, we had an elderly gentle man who came to visit our community and stayed with us for over a year. He wanted very much to stay and become a baptized member, but his wife did not want to. He asked if he could bring his wife and his daughter which was granted him. They stayed with us for a couple more months but his wife remained convinced that this was not the life for her. She and her daughter eventually returned to their home. The husband also followed, but with a heavy heart. He has been back almost every year since and stays with use and worships with us for a couple of months before returning again to his family. At no time was he told that his wife would not be welcome to stay, even if she chose not to become a member. If she had been content to live at our colony, without actually making a commitment, they would most likely have stayed. “And the woman [husband] which has a husband [wife] that believes not, and if he [she] be pleased to dwell with her [him], let her [him] not leave him [her]” 1 Cor. 7:13). Again, I apply this verse in a slightly different context than it was written, but I believe it helps to make the point.

I hope I have answered your questions sufficiently or have I just muddied the water?



Nickie said:

On: 15th Jun, 2012 at 12:52

Hi Ian-

What steps would someone have to go through to become members of your Hutterite Colony? Or if it would even be a possibility for us.
My husband and I have been discussing this, and we would like more information.

We were both brought up on dairy farms, raised as Christians, and we both know every aspect of living a self sustaining lifestyle, ie. raising livestock, crops, gardening, canning, sewing, cooking, etc.

Thank You,
Nickie



Ian said:

On: 16th Jun, 2012 at 01:33

One of the first steps would be to try and contact a colony that would be interested in hosting you for a visit. I would suggest maybe visiting this colony for a day or a weekend so that you can get a general feel and then decide if you would like to try it for a longer spell. Of course when determining how long you want to visit, you would have to take into consideration how close you live to this colony.



Nickie said:

On: 16th Jun, 2012 at 12:08

Hi Ian-

Thank you for your reply, do you know of any colonies that are open to hosting people for a visit? I took 3 yrs of german in high school, though it’s a bit rusty now. I do understand some still, and I would definitely brush up on it before I went to visit a colony. 🙂

I am very interested in going forward towards the next steps on this. Could you possibly email me privately any information that would be helpful. My email is nickielynn1973@yahoo.com

I really, really appreciate any help you may be able to give me about this.

daniel.flyger@k12.sd.us said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 20:36

I happened to stumble across the program on the NG channel.
I have had a fascination with the Hutterian Brethren since a small boy. I’ve lived near them most of my life. I’ve had the wonderful opportunity of being an “Englisch” school teacher in a Scmied colony for 25 years.
I will be honest and say that in those 25 years I’ve seen and heard a lot. Some of it has been a disappointment. I can honestly say that much that the public believes about the Hutterites is not so. I’ve seen them for all their flaws and faults.

This of course would be true, I believe, if anyone were to come and live amony us or come to our church too and spend much time among us as “English”.. I belong to a church that is also anabaptist but we’re not Hutterians. If someone were to spend a lot of time with us, they’d see us for what we are too, and not what we try to portray ourselves to be.

What I see as simply appalling by the King Ranch Colony is they are painting a bad picture of Hutterites. While I have observed the drinking and the smoking, I know that the latter is forbidden and drunken revelling is considered a sin.

I have heard an occasional curse word in both Hutterisch or English but I have never heard such filthy mouths among Hutterites as the movie shows and I have never heard Hutterites take God’s name in vain like Bertha does frequently.

I have never observed such blatant disrespect for the colony leadership. It causes me to seriously question what is actually wrong with the elders in this colony that they even allowed the film to be made?

Christians are to be a witness to the world. The Hutterites have long been “Stille ein landet” The quiet in the land, so though I have never observed anything so appalling among the Schmiedeleut, and only personally know a couple Darius people, this show is hurting the testimony of all. I should hope the elders deal with this situation.

As to education. A Jewish lady stated that education is seen good among the Jews. I just read a book written by a Jewish writer that says this has only come about in the last hundred years or so in America. Eastern European Jews were once suspect of worldly education.

I would agree with the elders that the Bible says “The wisdom of this world is foolishness with God.”

The people in this film would do well to be more concerned about their children’s souls and less concerned about their playing sports and public school indoctrinization.

I don’t want to be judgmental but the Bible says “By their fruits ye shall know them” so I guess we can be fruit inspectors.

The individuals in the American Colony show are showing spotted fruit. I have no doubt they’re not play acting. They talk that way and live that way and don’t seem to have any shame. That shows they feel no guilt and don’t feel it’s wrong and so it boils down to one’s spiritual condition.

If they weren’t already “worldly” I don’t think these boys would be going to public high school and playing sports, this girl wouldn’t be wearing cosmetics, they wouldn’t be wearing jewelry and the mother wouldn’t be cutting and painting her hair. They wouldn’t be sneaking off to smoke and fool around in sinful relationships; They wouldn’t be on the internet and have cell phones they are always talking or texting on. They wouldn’t be talking and jesting foolishly and they wouldn’t have foul mouths. I can’t emphasize how terrible this looks and sounds.

I can tell you not all Hutterites are like that. They’re not perfect, we’re all sinners, but this King Ranch outfit has a problem. They need to repent, pray, and read the Word of God. Maybe if they spent more time reading “Den Heilige Schrift.” and less time worrying about being “movie stars” things would be different among them.

I know in our church if a church was slipping from the straight and narrow, others of our Brethren from other congregations would come & attempt to straighten us out. I would hope the same thing happens with these folks, but none the less the harm is done.

I can tell you the people of the world, especially those who live in areas where Hutterites live, are laughing up their sleeves at this one. It will just give them more to be critical of the Hutterites for.

And the Hutterrites need not take it in stride and say, “Oh well, they’re just jealous of us and they’re only Enlisch folks anyway.”

The Apostle Paul warns all of us it’s one thing to be persecuted for our faith, but it’s quite another to be persecuted for unrighteous living. He warns that we need not thing we’ll receive anything but condemnation from our Lord for that.

Thanks for providing this blog, but I do know the most conservative element of the Hutterites would not even approve of that.

We all need to ask ourselves, what do we believe and why do we believe it? Then we need to live as the Good Book says, “That we might be able to give to those who ask of thee a reason for the hope that lies within you.”

Sonny said:

On: 6th Jun, 2012 at 21:16

What a breath of fresh air you are, Daniel! You’ve said it all! 🙂 Thank you!

“I can tell you the people of the world, especially those who live in areas where Hutterites live, are laughing up their sleeves at this one. It will just give them more to be critical of the Hutterites for.”

Here one needs to add… Der böse Feind lacht sich die Faust voll. (Lucifer laughs into his fist.)



Cathy G said:

On: 30th Jun, 2012 at 19:28

Well said Daniel, well said.

Linda Trzos said:

On: 7th Jun, 2012 at 08:10

I live in Lancaster, PA, and although I have no direct contact with anyone in a Hutterite community I do have some contact with my Amish neighbors. I have found them, on the whole, to be kind and peaceful.

I am “English,” and not of any religous tradition close to the Hutterites, Amish or Mennonite, but rather am Catholic. If I could live in a Catholic community and raise my children in a community like that I would. I love to learn and read. I have a BA and a Master’s degree, and hope that my children also pursue a higher education. But I homeschool my children, and one of the biggest reasons I do is because I don’t want them influenced by children who’s families do not share my value system. I sent my older two children to Catholic schools and they got a great education but they were influenced by the “worldliness” of the other students. People of other faiths, of no faith and of weak faith send their kids there and there is no denying that the influence of those other kids was harmful to mine.

Obviously any group is going to have people who push the envelope, as well as people who are out and out “bad.” Being Catholic, I know not even Church leaders are exempt from sin, even grave sin. I know better to judge an entire faith based upon a few people. The vast majority of Catholics and Catholic priests are good people, and I know that the vast majority of Hutterites are good as well. Even the ones in this community who are doing the envelope pushing are good people, in my opinion.

I hope this show does not negatively impact any Hutterite communities. I applaud the Hutterites for living out their faith their own way, and for wanting to keep their children in that faith. I pray for this colony, that they become more steadfast in their faith.

I’d also like to say I know that any reality tv show is only going to show glimpses of what Hutterite life is and that I don’t believe the behavior shown is typical.

Peace to you all and God bless.

Linda said:

On: 7th Jun, 2012 at 14:18

Thank you for your insightful comments, Linda Trzos! We all needed this. It’s true, this series is most likely not even an accurate representation of King Ranch, let alone all Hutterite communities. But embarrassing and disgusting nonetheless. It’s unfortunate that the producers chose to view the Hutterites through the eyes of rebellious teenagers, and then found National Geographic willing to broadcast their dream which as it turns out is nothing more than a nightmare. And we will survive, nights don’t last forever. “The Lord will give strength to His people; the Lord will bless his people with peace.” Ps. 29:11

Melissa said:

On: 7th Jun, 2012 at 14:08

I thought the first episode was very…fake? Maybe that’s not the correct word. While I didn’t think the whole show was fake, it seemed like they, Claudia in particular, were acting. I’m sure it was kind of exciting to have camera crews following them & they wanted to look more rebellious than they are? I only think that b/c the 2nd episode Claudia seems much more reserved and mature.
I would think the Religion aspect was kept more private on purpose. As they may not want to exploit their Religion & beliefs.
Either way, my husband & I enjoy the show. I love learning about different cultures and I hope the Hutterites (King Ranch & other colonies) will come to believe America appreciates them opening their doors for us to learn about them. 🙂

Friend said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 03:11

dear Mark,

This was very well-written and I completely agree with your insight. As a non-Hutterite (Catholic!) believer, I just watched the show in a hotel room on a business trip. I have to admit that I had never even heard of the Hutterites and I really enjoy studying other denominations. There was nothing at all about your beliefs on the show….so I googled them. I guess if everyone does the same, more Americans will learn about the group and hopefully not focus solely on the reality-tv style. Wishing you all Peace in Christ, Anne-Marie

Kf said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 05:00

Well done, N.M!! You are truly the voice of reason here.

Krisann said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 05:48

I have enjoyed reading the article and comments posted after just seeing the show for the first time. I also felt the show seemed somewhat contrived but it sparked my interest in Hutterites since I had no previous knowledge. I’ve now read much of the information on the org site as well. I relate to the desire to clarify misconceptions of one’s religion (I’m a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latterday Day Saints [LDS.org]) I wish the TV show focused on Why? And How? the faith directs the peoples’ day to day life. Not just the letter of the law Do’s and Don’ts but the Spirit of the Law. The show lacks the soul of Hutterites which is much clearer on this blog and the org site. I’m interested in learning more and extend my respect to all who live seeking God’s will and strive to keep love in their heart.

San Diego said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 06:12

They are just living life, trying to adapt, all the booze/drinking, language, dating, make up is them trying to adapt and grow as humans. The human condition is not easy, we all go through situations much more detrimental like sucide, illness, depression, war…. This is the reality in which we all live. So to me having a drink and saying a bad word and putting on a little makeup is not a bad action, butan adaptation. Let them be, youve all done something to cope with your own stress, so be weary before passing judgement.

dc said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 06:20

Does anyone know when/if the show airs in Canada. Our National Geo doesn’t show it up here …well, in Alberta .

Carmen said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 12:41

Hi all I am thankful for the link to this video http://www.nfb.ca/film/the_hutterites as it portrays a more accurate account of what life is like as a Hutterite. As a young LDS mother I have found it particularly difficult to teach and exemplify to my children that although we must live in the world, we must not be of the world.
My husband and I began watching the series this week. I didn’t know of Hudderites until now

Jim said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 13:56

I saw the show advertised on the NatGeo channel and hoped I would remember to watch it because the Hutterites are pretty amazing, in my humble opinion. As a teacher of American history, I knew of them as one of the many religious or philosophical communities that have been started in this country, then I learned of them again one day leafing through a magazine in a doctor’s office as there was a fascinating article about a genetics study done on them, and then again, in a completely random coincidence, my mother returned from a trip west with a piece of arts and crafts souvenir that she explained had purchased from a Hutterite.

That said, I did happen to catch the show, and I loved it. I am amazed at how vibrant Hutterite life is, and how successful they appear to be at maintaining the traditions of their church. Certainly the Shakers, Oneidans, Fourierists, Owenites et al could have learned from these people. One earlier commenter mentioned the Catholic faith and another mentioned the Jewish faith, both of which are great examples of religions that have many many followers in name only. (As evidence I offer the recent poll in Ireland in which only one-fourth of the Catholics polled believed in transubstantiation, which is the centerpiece of that faith, and the many many Jews I know who only keep kosher, if at all, on major holy days). The Hutterites live their faith 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and it’s not an easy faith to live. Despite the disappointment expressed over this series, this outsider is extremely impressed, even by this “rogue” colony.

In fact, when the next episode was on, I told my children that they should watch as well. They did, and we are all impressed with the “characters” on the show and their ability to express their thoughts and emotions articulately, earnestly, and largely without guile. As a high school teacher of twenty years, I assure you that the level of disrespect, destructive behavior and foul language shown on the program is a tiny fraction of what we would see in mainstream American society. The fact that the two boys willingly gave up sports and school, without being strong-armed by their parent, simply because their mother was in emotional distress, speaks volumes about the hearts of these people.

I have a friend who was approached to do a reality show about his business, and the production crew literally coached him through everything they wanted him to do to make good television. “OK, can you light that burner again please, looking more intense this time. Ok, good, one more time please, this time looking at the match as you strike it.” I have no idea whether the production company used for American Colony was as pushy as the crew that did my friend’s show, but I have no doubt that the people in the colony were cajoled into acting and doing certain things that they might not normally do by the producer.

So, in the end of this too long comment, please allow me to express my appreciation for the show, and my admiration for the people of the King Ranch Colony, and the Hutterites community at large. You impress me in your example of faith, and may God bless you all.

Michael said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 19:25

Well, I really enjoyed this post and found it very thoughtful and well written. Thank you. I especially think your final paragraph wraps up the realities of a show like this. I was part of a reality based program about my business for three seasons and to this day spend a lot of time dispelling the perception put upon me by the editorial decisions of the producers. From the first episode of American Colony, I saw many of the same techniques being used to tell their story. Thankfully, I believe most viewers are smart enough to see this as a small sampling of a larger community.

As someone who prides himself on studying and learning about the various religious beliefs around the world, I was totally in the dark about hutterite tradition, so take some comfort in knowing that there are those like me who have taken this show as an introduction and now begin our own investigation via sites like this etc. to better understand the hutterite way. Take care.

Robin Kincaid said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 21:55

Dear Sir:
First, I would like to say that tthe positive thing about the TV show “American Colony” is that it has led me to research further into the ‘truth’ as to what it is to be a Hutterite. I agree with your well-written blog that the show is depicting a particular colony and I also believe that when on television people do behave differently, even if unconsciously – they have a captured audience and young people, any youngsters, really find they like this. I also agree that what sets the Hutterites apart from society, their unique religious beliefs, should have been a good portion of this program – these beliefs were what I was most interested in understanding.

I did like to view the Hutterites as human beings; the show did a very good job of this. For many English people, we see your group eating in restaurants, etc. and your dress is the most striking thing we notice and obviously identifies you as Hutterite (or the ill-informed believe you to be Amish or Mennonite). You were always a people of mystery to me as I was growing up. For better or worse, technology (the TV and the internet) now brings a better understanding and yes, even respect from some of us outsiders. But with such good awareness the negative is that you must struggle as a people to keep safe your culture, traditions, language and religious beliefs that are the core of your specialness.
As much as your Colonies treasure separation/isolation largely from the outer society, with some familiarity there is less bias and prejudice from English people; there is more acceptance of your people. With this acceptance, not just tolerance, your people will be allowed to farm your lands and pray undisturbed in your paradise on earth for generations to come. You will remain a free people on your land.
God Bless your “simple ways” and may your people follow His Way for centuries to come. Thank you for sharing with us outsiders a little bit of the manner in which you live, work and pray. It takes great courage and conviction to live as you do.

Brenda said:

On: 13th Jun, 2012 at 23:48

I just watched the National Geographic show and was aware that the show misses the reason you all live in community: your vital relationship with Jesus Christ.

SWS said:

On: 14th Jun, 2012 at 00:44

I watch the show “The American Colony”, and I enjoy it. Of course, I find any culture or belief different from mine interesting, and I love to learn about them. I try not to judge anyone’s belief, and in return, I expect no one to judge my belief. I am assuming that there are some colonies that have a stricter code and possibly a more leaner code of rules and expectations than the colony portrayed on TV. The question I wanted to asked was “Can a person convert to be a Hutterite?” I know from the show that if someone marries from outside the colony then they have to leave, but what if the bride or groom wants to join the colony and embrace the faith. Would that be allowed?

Mark Waldner said:

On: 14th Jun, 2012 at 01:20

SWS, it has happened that outsiders or non-Hutterites join a Hutterite colony, but it is quite rare. Few Hutterite colony are open to outsider joining, but there are a handful who would consider it, depending on the candidate and the willingness of the candidate to adopt to the Hutterian norms. Over the year’s many people have attempted to become full members of the Hutterite community, but haven’t been successful for a variety of reasons, including a language barrior. You can read a more detailed response in our FAQs section at
https://7nn.010.mwp.accessdomain.com/day-to-day/faqs/

Leah said:

On: 15th Jun, 2012 at 13:28

What a lovely and diplomatic view of the show.

Oges Ziggy said:

On: 15th Jun, 2012 at 15:33

I have enjoyed watching the show to learn more about this group of people, what I do not understand is that the boys cannot play sports, go to High School and spend time with electronics, as it is the Elders’ way, but you can go on National TV. Is that no a contridiction to what the Elders teach. Life if moving along fast and furious, allowing the children to futher their education will not hurt your Colony, they will be more experienced, have more expertise and knowledge and will be able to provide a better living to All if they are allowed to flourish. I applaud Rita and Bertha for standing behind their children, they have not turned their heads against the Colony or the teaching, but they are realistic and see that the future lies with learning and knowledge!

Oges Ziggy said:

On: 15th Jun, 2012 at 15:40

I applaud Rita and Bertha for sticking up for their children, both of these ladies, have not disrespected the Colony or their fellow neighbors for believing that the future should be about the invested of the children. Playing sports, going to High School or learning does not make a child run for cover, it is the unfair rules and regulations that turn young America away. The world is changing fast and furious and with knowledge comes power! It is interesting that the Elders (who live in Canada) can rule with an iron fist! As I have witnessed from watching the program the activities of the older men seem very much out of character from the teachings therefore they also seem to be rebeling! And lastly if the Elders are against such modern teachings and technology why are the lives of Colony allowed to be played out on public display, it seems like the story of everyone world wide, what’s good for one is not always good for another!

Ian said:

On: 16th Jun, 2012 at 01:49

Ziggy, I would like to point out that among the Hutterites there is a huge difference in the approach to education, tolerance to sports, music, etc. As with most cultures or religious groups, you have leaders and people who are very conservative and you have some that are very liberal. This is also true for Hutterites. There are many colonies that place a high premium on education. Many colony allow their young people to participate in sports such as hockey, volleyball, basketball, softball, etc. There is really no “norm” that applies to all colonies. What you see in the documentary might be the norm for the King Ranch colony or for the particular branch of Hutterites they are part of but it is not the norm in many other colonies.